MAYBELLINENew York Hyper Easy Liquid Pen No-Skip Waterproof Eyeliner, Satin Finish, Pitch Brown

I am not a makeup person by that I mean o can’t do any liners evenly. BUT THIS GEM has my eyes looking flawless and effortlessly. It’s non irritating. You chose how thick or thin you want your wing and with one quick slide it is spot on my lash line. High quality, long lasting, and easily removed. Forever a fan. Will buy again and again.

Good Waterproof, my eyes water up and even from laughing it makes most eyeliner smear. This one works well and stays in place all day. I actually ordered extra ones a few days after my first purchase to make sure I don't run out. Great! For sensitive eyes

I love this liner. I have used waterproof liner before and dries out my eyelids. This one doesn't do that and goes on so easily. It's my new favorite liner.

The eyeliner goes on smoothly however, I wouldn’t really call the line it creates a “fine” line or “thin” line, if that’s what you’re looking for. I use it on my top water line below my upper lashes so it works fine for me. It’s pretty dark brown so it’s difficult to tell if it’s black or brown. I was looking for a little bit softer of a brown color but for the price it will suffice. 4 ⭐️ rather than 5 ⭐️ simply because of the color.

This is my favorite liquid eyeliner, it’s intense, super smooth to put on, but once you put it somewhere it is STUCK so just beware. Sometimes it is too wet and can be messy, just dab excess off with a piece of toilet paper or something!

This eyeliner is okay, but I'm not a big fan of the brush tip. It frayed out pretty quickly, and I wasn't a big fan of how the product came off the brush at first compared to my others. It definitely was not my favorite tip but i got used to it . If you don't have a lot of experience, then this is not the tip for you. I did okay with it, but in the morning, I'm tired and don't always feel ad steady, and it's made a mess of your not careful, and it does smear and flow out!The good thing about this eyeliner is that it does flow off easily w little effort and has a shaker ball to stir it. It goes a long way and didn't dry out like some, so if it weren't for the brush issues, I would have gotten months more! I use my eyeliner every day, maybe skipping a day here and there, but I had this all summer and then kinda kept pulling the loose frayed to make it last longer through fall, till i got sick.of it and opened the next one discarding all the eyelin lift in the tube . It is very black, also, which is good and what i like.The brush is fine, and before it frayed, it was nice for detailing the fine line I do. I got two, so I'm hoping the second will be a better experience with the fraying of the brush because if it weren't for that, I would give it four stars! This time I'm a lot more careful with how I lay it and close it. I Make sure you lay it up because the product will flow down and make a mess because of how liquidy thin the liner is!

This is such a good liquid eyeliner. It stays on all day and is easy to take off.

I really like this product. I have had trouble with it pooling over if leaking. Makes a mess on your hands and extra caution doesn’t drip on your face. It every wand has done this. Even with all that it definitely applies the product nicely.